Sugarloaf Key Homes with Yes Pets allowed

Sugarloaf Key Homes with Yes Pets allowed

Welcome to Sugarloaf Key, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of the Florida Keys! This enchanting island, part of Monroe County, offers a unique blend of laid-back island living and vibrant natural beauty. With its lush landscapes, stunning waterfront views, and a warm, welcoming community, Sugarloaf Key is the perfect destination for those seeking a tranquil retreat or a vibrant lifestyle.

One of the most appealing aspects of Sugarloaf Key is its pet-friendly environment. Many homes in this charming area proudly welcome furry companions, allowing you to enjoy the island life with your beloved pets by your side. Imagine waking up to the gentle sound of waves, taking leisurely strolls along the picturesque streets, or enjoying a sunset on your porch with your four-legged friend. The island's natural beauty and serene atmosphere make it an ideal place for both you and your pets to thrive.

Sugarloaf Key boasts a variety of homes, from cozy cottages to spacious waterfront properties, each designed to embrace the island's unique charm. The community is known for its friendly neighbors and a strong sense of belonging, making it easy to feel right at home. With easy access to nearby attractions, including beautiful beaches, local shops, and outdoor adventures, you’ll find endless opportunities to explore and enjoy life in this tropical paradise.

Whether you're looking for a permanent residence or a vacation getaway, Sugarloaf Key is the perfect place to create lasting memories with your loved ones, including your beloved pets. Discover the beauty and warmth of this island oasis today!

Newest Sugarloaf Key Homes with Yes Pets allowed

1041 Buttonwood Dr, Sugarloaf
$9,970,000
6 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 621794 MLS
THE AZURE ESTATE | Where Luxury Meets Wellness. Discover a stunning, brand-new solid concrete architectural masterpiece on the open waters of Sugarloaf Key, where striking design, coastal resilience, and wellness-inspired luxury create an extraordinary Florida Keys lifestyle. Designed for strength and peace of mind, this remarkable elevated residence pairs hurricane-resistant design features with walls of glass and endless ocean views. Step inside to a breathtaking 19-foot, double-height living room filled with natural light. Porcelain floors, elegant glass railings, and a private hydraulic elevator bring comfort and sophistication to every level. The chef's kitchen dazzles with quartzite countertops and Monogram appliances, complemented by a custom bar and dramatic stone wine display. Four private suites in the main residence open to covered waterfront terraces, inviting you to wake up to endless ocean views and gentle island breezes. Crowning the home, a full rooftop deck offers sweeping 360-degree panoramas from sunrise to sunset-an inspiring retreat for morning yoga, meditation, or unforgettable gatherings under the stars. Outside, a resort-style pool and spa, outdoor shower, convenient poolside bathroom, landscape lighting, and expansive covered entertaining areas invite you to slow down and savor island life. A planned 226-foot dock, included in the purchase price, will further elevate the boating experience. One of the property's most distinctive features is its solid reinforced-concrete parking structure, designed to accommodate up to 6 vehicles, with generous overhead storage space and convenient dual access. Boasting an impressive elevation of 11 ft 2 inch NGVD, above the designated 10-ft NGVD flood elevation, this structure offers a significant advantage in the Florida Keys, providing an added measure of protection against potential flooding during hurricanes, storm surges, and severe weather conditions. Built with solid structural concrete throughout!

1041 Buttonwood Dr, Sugarloaf
265 S Point Dr, Sugarloaf
$2,549,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 621772 MLS
Exceptional waterfront living in prestigious Sugarloaf Shores! Built in 2020, this stunning 4-bedroom, 3-bath home offers breathtaking open water views, spectacular sunrises, and the perfect blend of coastal elegance and Florida Keys living. Thoughtfully designed with 2,594 square feet of living space, this beautiful home features a spacious open floor plan, split-bedroom layout, and two additional bonus rooms with the potential for extra bedrooms, offering flexibility for family and guests. The inviting living and dining areas flow seamlessly into a gorgeous kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances, generous counter space, and plenty of room for entertaining. The spacious primary suite offers a walk-in closet and a beautifully appointed bathroom complete with a soaking tub and separate walk-in shower. Step outside onto the covered porch and take in the breathtaking sunrise views overlooking the sparkling open water. Enjoy your own private waterfront retreat, complete with a saltwater swimming pool, concrete dock, and boat lift, making it easy to embrace the boating and outdoor lifestyle the Florida Keys are known for. Elevated construction provides an expansive ground-level area featuring covered parking, two separate storage rooms, and a spacious concrete-finished outdoor living and entertainment area with plenty of room to relax, gather, and enjoy the tropical surroundings. Additional features include hurricane-impact windows and doors, Hardie board siding, and a fully fenced property. Located just 15 minutes from Key West, this exceptional Sugarloaf Shores property offers the beauty of peaceful waterfront living with convenient access to everything the Lower Florida Keys have to offer. Whether you're enjoying your morning coffee as the sun rises over the water, spending the day boating, or relaxing poolside, this home truly captures the Florida Keys lifestyle!

265 S Point Dr, Sugarloaf
17162 W Starfish Ln, Sugarloaf
$6,400,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 621741 MLS
Stunning coastal architecture. Exceptional craftsmanship. Effortless waterfront luxury. This BRAND new home pairs classic Keys architecture with modern coastal elegance and quality concrete construction in sought-after Sugarloaf Key, just 20 mins from Key West. Set on a 12,500-square-foot lot with 100 feet of waterfrontage, this turnkey five-bedroom, five-bath home (ALL SUITES) overlooks a wide canal with beautiful turquoise water and abundant marine life. Thoughtfully curated architectural details and exquisite finishes reflect a commitment to quality throughout. A soaring 14FT vaulted entry welcomes you to European French oak floors and 8FT solid doors. Open-concept living, dining, kitchen and bar spaces flow through stacking Euro-Wall glass doors to the home's spectacular centerpiece: an expansive covered waterfront balcony with 14FT vaulted cypress ceilings. The chef's kitchen features Thermador appliances, wine & beverage centers, ice machine, handcrafted hammered stainless steel hood, Kohler water filtration & ambient lighting. All five bedrooms are ensuite; the primary bath offers ambient lighting, a soaking tub and separate water closet. Lush landscaping surrounds an enormous 1900 SFT outdoor entertaining area with travertine terraces, a spectacular pool, sun shelf & an elevated eight-person spa. A handcrafted live-edge monkeypod bar has electric roll-down hurricane shutters for quick, secure lockup and storm protection. An 80FT concrete dock, seawall, 15,000 LB boat lift & dockside utilities invite world-class fishing and diving adventures just minutes away. The enormous garage features hurricane-rated doors with LiftMaster side-mount openers; parking areas are provisioned for EV charging. A security system, two LG washer-dryer sets, solar panels to the grid, electric bedroom shades, hurricane-rated windows & doors complete this exceptional home. Meticulous attention to detail defines this stunning home, close to local dining & the magic of Key West!

17162 W Starfish Ln, Sugarloaf
17155 W Hibiscus Ln, Sugarloaf
$949,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 621720 MLS
WATERFRONT PARADISE IN THE MAKING! TROPICAL TREASURE & ENDLESS POSSIBILITIES! Some properties have potential but this one already has paradise written all over it! Discover an exceptional waterfront opportunity in beautiful Sugarloaf Key, where wide, deep, swimmable canals, outstanding boating opportunities, and picturesque partial open-water views of Sugarloaf Bay set the stage for the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle! Nestled on a generously sized lot surrounded by lush, mature tropical vegetation, this property offers a wonderful sense of privacy, natural beauty, and peaceful island living. Located in a wonderful neighborhood with palm-tree-lined sidewalks, it's the perfect setting for leisurely strolls, tropical breezes, and enjoying the relaxed Keys atmosphere. Boating enthusiasts will appreciate the spacious, deep-water canal, with access to both back country boating and Ocean side! While nature lovers will fall in love with the beautiful greenery, tranquil waterfront setting, and inviting waters right outside their door. The home offers an exciting opportunity for renovation, allowing buyers to create their own spectacular coastal retreat while enjoying the many desirable features this property already provides. Exterior is done in concrete board and newly painted with new composite decking. Solar System paid for with low electric bills! Just Imagine adding a sparkling resort-style pool, a fabulous tiki hut for entertaining, and a boat lift to complete your waterfront oasis! Whether you're an investor seeking a value-add opportunity or a buyer dreaming of a personalized island escape, the combination of beautiful waterfront surroundings, exceptional boating, privacy, and neighborhood charm makes this property truly special. The location is captivating, the waterfront is incredible, and the possibilities are endless! Bring your imagination and transform this tropical treasure into your own piece of Keys paradise in the desirable and in demand Sugarloaf Key!

17155 W Hibiscus Ln, Sugarloaf
17015 W Wahoo Ln, Sugarloaf
$3,999,999
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 621652 MLS
Rarely does a waterfront setting capture the essence of the Florida Keys quite like this. Occupying a spectacular west-facing point lot with 270 feet of open-water frontage on Sugarloaf Sound, this fully reimagined 3-bedroom, 3-bath estate offers breathtaking sunsets, sweeping turquoise-water views, and the privacy of a secluded island retreat. Beyond the gated entrance, a 17,000-square-foot property unfolds with swaying palms, lush tropical landscaping, and an extraordinary connection to the water. CBS construction, a new aluminum standing-seam metal roof, and impact windows and doors provide a solid foundation for the home's refined coastal-modern design. Inside, walls of glass frame panoramic water views and fill the expansive open-concept living spaces with natural light. Tile plank flooring, clean architectural lines, and a serene palette bring understated elegance throughout. At the heart of the home, a chef's kitchen pairs an oversized waterfall-edge island with custom cabinetry, high-end stainless appliances, wine refrigeration, and designer lighting, all against a spectacular open-water backdrop. The waterfront primary suite is a peaceful escape, complete with a spa-inspired bath featuring dual vanities, custom tilework, and a frameless glass walk-in shower. Two additional beautifully appointed ensuite guest bedrooms offer private, comfortable retreats for family and visitors. Outside, a brand-new concrete pool, inviting tiki hut, and unusually generous lawn create a private resort atmosphere for relaxing and entertaining. As the sun dips over Sugarloaf Sound, the outdoor spaces become a front-row setting for spectacular skies and unforgettable evenings. A 14,000-pound boat lift adds convenience after days spent fishing and diving in the Lower Keys. Fully renovated and move-in ready, this exceptional Sugarloaf Key estate brings together unforgettable sunsets, modern comfort, and the freedom of waterfront living.

17015 W Wahoo Ln, Sugarloaf
17050 Old State Rd Unit 4A, Sugarloaf
$949,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 621613 MLS
Tucked away on nearly 3 acres of lush native landscape, this Sugarloaf Key home has incredible privacy, with non-buildable land surrounding the property. The 2-bedroom, 2-bath concrete home has 2,280 sqft of living space, with poured concrete floors and roof, and an impressive ~2,700 sqft of balconies. Inside, large windows and sliding glass doors bring in plenty of natural light, and the home feels open and spacious with plenty of room to make it your own. The ~980 sqft rooftop terrace is one of the best parts, with views over the nature preserve and out toward the ocean, plus a spot to catch both the sunrise and sunset. A walkway winds through the property toward the oceanfront, making it easy to get outside and enjoy the surroundings. Downstairs, there's a ~500 sqft enclosure with an internal staircase, along with a covered carport and gated entrance. With this much outdoor space, privacy, and views in every direction, it's a pretty special spot on Sugarloaf Key.

17050 Old State Rd Unit 4A, Sugarloaf
1481 Sugarloaf Blvd, Sugarloaf
$1,650,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 621568 MLS
Welcome to this spacious canal-front retreat set on an oversized half-acre lot with endless potential. This four-bedroom, 2,605 sq ft home offers a rare combination of water access, outdoor living, and privacy. Enjoy true Florida Keys living with a private concrete boat ramp, a dock, and direct canal access leading to mangrove-lined creeks and open water just minutes away. Whether you're exploring by paddleboard or kayak, or heading out on your boat to world-class fishing and diving, this location makes it effortless. The backyard is designed for relaxation and connection, featuring a pool, spa, and multiple outdoor patio areas, all surrounded by lush, mature tropical landscaping. Inside, the home features a renovated kitchen, bright open living spaces, and a large enclosed back porch that extends your living area and overlooks the pool, spa, and canal. With four bedrooms, generous square footage, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow, the home is ideal as a primary residence, seasonal getaway, or investment property with tremendous upside. Located just minutes from Key West yet surrounded by the peace and natural beauty of Sugarloaf, this property offers the best of both worlds--space, privacy, and direct water access that's hard to find, along with the freedom to create your ideal island retreat.

1481 Sugarloaf Blvd, Sugarloaf
1151 Sugarloaf Blvd, Sugarloaf
$1,499,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 621524 MLS
Truly unique and private estate property on the desired Sugarloaf Blvd. in Sugarloaf Shores. Ground level CBS house sits on 2 waterfront lots. Totaling over 1.3 acres of land and approx. 400 ft. of canal front. Amazing view up the canal to the open water. The large floor plan featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, den/office and fireplace. Kitchen has stainless appliances, quartz countertops and lots of storage for your inner chef needs. Covered back porch perfect for outdoor entertaining. Keep all your fishing equipment and/or water toys nicely organized in the large 2 car garage with laundry, extra freezer and storage shelves. Enjoy the ease of launching kayaks and paddle boards from your own private ramp into the canal.

1151 Sugarloaf Blvd, Sugarloaf
19590 Tequesta St, Sugarloaf
$739,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 621432 MLS
Located in the quiet Indian Mounds neighborhood of Upper Sugarloaf Key, this elevated 3 bedroom, 2 bath home offers 1,296 square feet of comfortable living space. Impact-resistant windows and doors rated for winds up to 180 mph provide enhanced storm protection and valuable insurance savings. The open concept interior features crown molding and wood look tile plank flooring throughout. The kitchen is equipped with solid wood cabinetry and stainless steel appliances. The well-designed floor plan includes a large primary suite with an en suite bathroom and walk-in closet, two guest bedrooms, a second full bathroom, and a full-size laundry room. Outside, the home features low-maintenance Hardie Board siding, a durable metal roof, and a spacious covered porch located just off the kitchen. The yard is fenced on three sides, and the back porch overlooks mature tropical trees with no rear neighbors, providing a lush, natural backdrop. Boaters and anglers will appreciate the convenient location near multiple boat ramps, including access to a private community ramp, offering quick access to open water. The home is also minutes from the Upper Sugarloaf Key nature preserve and Sugarloaf Elementary and Middle School. Whether you are searching for a primary residence, Florida Keys retreat, or investment property, this move-in-ready home offers comfort and convenient access to the outdoor lifestyle of the Lower Keys.

19590 Tequesta St, Sugarloaf
19421 Canal Dr, Sugarloaf
$699,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 620938 MLS
Great opportunity to have your home in a charming neighborhood on Sugarloaf key, MM 19.5. Enjoy your 3-bedroom 2-bath single family home on a large 15000 sq ft lot with screened front porch and open patio in the backyard. This large yard has plenty of room for a pool, Boats, RV, Trailers and your toys! Home is located down the street from Sugarloaf School, 20 miles to Key West and 27 miles to Marathon. Home has been updated with custom kitchen cabinets, updated bathrooms, has central air, stainless steel appliances.. Easy to show.

19421 Canal Dr, Sugarloaf
182 Venetian Way, Sugarloaf
$1,595,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 620823 MLS
Experience classic Florida Keys waterfront living in this spacious canal-front retreat on Sugarloaf Key, offering boating access, expansive indoor-outdoor living, and just a short drive to Key West. 3,000 square feet of finished living space including 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. Situated on a wide canal with ample room for a future dock, offering the opportunity to create your own boating paradise. The massive chef's kitchen features copious marble countertops, abundant cabinetry, generous seating, and opens seamlessly into the impressive great room--ideal for entertaining family and friends. The open concept living spaces open onto a large canal-side deck that extends your living space outdoors. The spacious primary suite offers tranquil canal views and a spa-inspired bath with a soaking tub positioned to take in the waterfront scenery. A skylit bonus room offers endless possibilities as a fitness room, artist's studio, or sunroom. The nicely landscaped 13,000-square-foot property offers a circular drive, mature tropical plantings, and abundant parking for guests, boats, and recreational vehicles. Whether you're seeking a full-time residence, seasonal escape, or exceptional waterfront investment, this distinctive Sugarloaf Key home offers the space, setting, and Florida Keys lifestyle you've been waiting for.

182 Venetian Way, Sugarloaf
19543 Navajo St, Sugarloaf
$749,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 620391 MLS
3 bed 2 bath stilt home built in 2018 in sought after Sugarloaf Key. Open concept floor plan, large kitchen with an abundance of large white cabinets, kitchen island overlooking living area, stainless steel appliances, light and stylish colors throughout. Wood-look tile plank flooring, crown molding, 9-ft ceilings, recessed lighting and ceiling fans in all bedrooms and living room. Full size laundry room and on-demand hot water heater. Large master bedroom with en-suite bathroom, dual sink vanity and large walk-in closet. 2 guest bedrooms and full guest bathroom. Large covered porch off the main living/kitchen area, fenced on 3 sides. Newer downstairs storage room, room for boat/trailer; boat ramp is one street over and you are less than a mile from Sugarloaf Elementary and Middle school. Quick access to Key West and bases.

19543 Navajo St, Sugarloaf
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!