Sugarloaf Key Homes with Other Subtype

Welcome to Sugarloaf Key, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Florida's Monroe County. This enchanting island, part of the beautiful Florida Keys, offers a unique blend of laid-back island living and vibrant natural beauty. Known for its stunning sunsets and crystal-clear waters, Sugarloaf Key is a paradise for those seeking tranquility and adventure in equal measure.

With a diverse selection of homes available, Sugarloaf Key caters to a variety of lifestyles and preferences. Whether you’re dreaming of a cozy waterfront cottage or a spacious modern retreat, the homes here are designed to embrace the island's charm while offering the comforts of contemporary living. Many properties feature lush tropical landscaping, private docks, and breathtaking views, making them perfect for anyone looking to immerse themselves in the island life.

The community is characterized by its friendly atmosphere, where neighbors become friends and local businesses thrive. Residents enjoy access to a plethora of outdoor activities, from boating and fishing to kayaking and snorkeling. The nearby nature preserves and parks provide ample opportunities for hiking and birdwatching, allowing you to connect with the island's rich wildlife.

Sugarloaf Key is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. Imagine waking up to the soothing sounds of the ocean, spending your days exploring the vibrant coral reefs, and ending your evenings with the sun setting over the horizon. If you’re looking for a home that embodies the essence of island living, Sugarloaf Key is the perfect destination to call your own. Come discover your slice of paradise in this idyllic Florida enclave!

Newest Sugarloaf Key Homes with Other Subtype

$950,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 619875 MLS

On a quiet dead-end street in the highly sought-after Sugarloaf Shores community, sits this fully renovated tropical retreat thats reminiscent of something straight out of a secret garden. Set on an oversized, gated and partially fenced parcel spanning over a quarter acre, this rare non-waterfront property offers the kind of lush green space that's nearly impossible to find in the Florida Keys. Towering old-growth foliage, vibrant established plantings, fresh new landscaping, and newly laid sod create a private, enchanted oasis where every corner invites you to slow down and stay awhile. Built in 1981 of solid concrete block construction and elevated on slab, this beautifully reimagined 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 1,548 square feet of airy, light-filled living space with bright neutral finishes and thoughtful details throughout. Every inch has been meticulously renovated, blending modern comfort with effortless island charm. Designed to embrace indoor-outdoor living, the property features multiple lanais and entertaining spaces perfect for morning coffee beneath the palms, sunset dinners with friends, or quiet afternoons surrounded by tropical serenity. The expansive lot offers endless opportunity for future enhancements -- envision a resort-style pool and tiki hut, a greenhouse, outdoor kitchen, play space for the kids, or all of the above. There's room here to truly create your dream Keys compound. Downstairs, nearly 400 additional square feet of enclosed storage and utility space adds incredible flexibility, while the paved 3-car carport with lighting and built-in workspace could easily be transformed into the ultimate outdoor entertaining kitchen or hobby space. Beloved Sugarloaf Shores provides peaceful island living with a scenic miles-long paved path, a laid-back Lower Keys atmosphere, and sought-after school district -- all just 15 minutes from exciting Key West. Rare Keys privacy, greenery, and possibility you may never want to leave.

123 Venetian Way, Sugarloaf

$799,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 619536 MLS

Opportunities like this are hard to find in the Lower Keys--this fully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home sits on a generous half-acre lot in the highly desirable Sugarloaf Key area, offering space, privacy, and modern upgrades throughout. Designed for easy coastal living, the home features durable Hardie board siding, a long-lasting metal roof, tile flooring throughout, and an energy-efficient tankless water heater. Inside, you'll find a bright, open layout that flows effortlessly to an expansive screened porch--perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Step outside to a 24' x 24' sun deck overlooking the oversized yard, where there's ample room to add a pool, store your toys, utilize the existing RV hookup, or enjoy fresh mangos right off the trees. The ground level provides covered parking for two vehicles and an abundance of space for additional uncovered parking. Ideally located near multiple boat ramps, this property is a dream for boating and fishing enthusiasts. You'll also be just minutes from the natural beauty of the Upper Sugarloaf Nature Preserve, the local Sugarloaf School, and a variety of popular dining spots. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, vacation home, or investment property in the Florida Keys, this move-in-ready home checks all the boxes.

937 Loggerhead Ln, Sugarloaf

Start Your Search