Sugarloaf Key Homes with Bay Waterfront features

Welcome to Sugarloaf Key, a hidden gem nestled in the enchanting Florida Keys, where the azure waters of the Gulf of Mexico meet the lush tropical landscapes. Located in Monroe County, Sugarloaf Key is a serene paradise that offers a unique blend of natural beauty and vibrant island living. As you explore this charming community, you'll discover that it is not just a place to live; it's a lifestyle defined by relaxation, adventure, and a profound connection to nature.

One of the most appealing features of Sugarloaf Key is its stunning bay waterfront homes. Imagine waking up to the gentle sound of waves lapping at your doorstep and breathtaking views of the sun setting over the water. These properties offer a rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise with direct access to the bay, making it perfect for boating enthusiasts, fishing aficionados, or anyone who simply enjoys the tranquility of waterfront living.

The homes here are designed to complement the island's natural beauty, featuring spacious layouts, modern amenities, and outdoor spaces that invite you to soak in the warm Florida sun. Whether you're looking for a cozy retreat or a luxurious estate, Sugarloaf Key has something to offer for everyone.

With its close-knit community, vibrant local culture, and endless opportunities for outdoor recreation, Sugarloaf Key is more than just a place to live; it's a lifestyle that embraces the essence of island living. Come discover the magic of Sugarloaf Key and find your dream waterfront home today!

Newest Sugarloaf Key Homes with Bay Waterfront features

$5,200,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 618184 MLS

Introducing Blue Sky Pointe - the crown jewel of Sugarloaf Key. Perched on a gated 33,750 sq. ft. peninsula with approximately 730 feet of waterfront, this spectacular 4 Bed, 3.5 Bath modern coastal showpiece is surrounded by glistening water and enjoys Keys famous sunset views over Sugarloaf Sound. Fully renovated with premium craftsmanship, the home features a standing seam metal roof, PGT impact windows/doors, and Hardi board siding. Inside, enjoy a sunlit open-concept floor plan with soaring ceilings, a gourmet kitchen with quartz counters, premium stainless appliances, gas stove, a hidden butler's pantry, and a waterfront Bedroom wing, all oriented to frame the water from every room. Step outside and immerse yourself in resort-style living with a heated and chilled waterfront pool, soothing spa, hot tub, invigorating cold plunge, and a fire pit encircled by flickering tiki torches to gather with friends and family while sipping cocktails as the sun melts into the horizon. Lounge on the expansive covered porch while enjoying views of the peaceful nature preserve for incredible bird watching, and a setting that offers total privacy and serenity. Boaters will love the protected canal access with 2 boat lifts (8K & 12K lbs), just minutes from open water. Additional features include a 4-car garage with EV charger, covered RV Tiki with 50 amp service, whole-house 35kW generator (750-gal tank), whole house water softening system and Sonos throughout, including garage and outdoor zones. Whether you're seeking a private sanctuary, a trophy lot, or the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle, Blue Sky Pointe delivers. This is the most premiere lot on Sugarloaf Key — a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

17013 Coral Dr, Sugarloaf

$2,849,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 618874 MLS

Experience breathtaking sunsets over Sugarloaf Sound from this 2-story CBS open water estate offering 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, and 2,170 sq ft of elevated coastal living just 20 minutes from Key West. Situated on a generous 15,650 sq ft lot, this meticulously maintained home features impact doors and windows, metal roof, exterior elevator, and lush tropical landscaping including a dedicated orchid house for the gardening enthusiast. The main living level showcases a stunning Great Room with soaring tongue-and-groove ceilings and panoramic water views. The open kitchen overlooks Sugarloaf Sound and offers bar seating, stainless appliances, and gas range. A dining area with Dade County Pine accent wall adds warmth and character. The entire second floor is devoted to the private Primary Suite retreat, complete with walk-in closet, sitting room, and spectacular water views for morning coffee with the sunrise and evenings watching the Keys' famous sunsets. Outdoor living is exceptional with a waterfront heated and chilled pool, covered lanai for entertaining, outdoor shower, tiki hut, and private dock with 12,000 lb boat lift offering easy open water access. Every evening, the sky ignites in gold and crimson as the sun melts into Sugarloaf Sound. This is not just a home, it is a front-row seat to one of the Florida Keys' most extraordinary natural performances.

17041 Marlin Dr, Sugarloaf

Start Your Search