Flamingo Island (49.5) Homes for Sale

Flamingo Island (49.5) Homes for Sale

Welcome to Flamingo Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Marathon, Florida, within the stunning Monroe County. This idyllic subdivision is a paradise for those seeking a blend of tranquility and vibrant island life. Flamingo Island boasts a unique charm, characterized by its lush landscapes, serene waterfront views, and a warm, welcoming community atmosphere.

Homes for sale in Flamingo Island offer a diverse range of architectural styles, from cozy bungalows to luxurious waterfront estates. Each property is designed to maximize the breathtaking views and embrace the natural beauty that surrounds this enchanting area. Imagine waking up to the gentle sounds of the ocean and enjoying your morning coffee on a sun-drenched patio, with the promise of a perfect day ahead.

Residents of Flamingo Island enjoy a lifestyle that includes access to pristine beaches, world-class fishing, and an array of outdoor recreational activities. Whether you prefer kayaking through crystal-clear waters, exploring nearby nature trails, or simply soaking up the sun, this community has it all. Additionally, the vibrant city of Marathon offers a variety of dining, shopping, and entertainment options, ensuring that you never run out of exciting things to do.

With homes for sale in Flamingo Island, now is the perfect time to invest in your dream home in this picturesque slice of paradise. Don’t miss the opportunity to be part of a community that captures the essence of Florida living. Explore the possibilities and let Flamingo Island be the backdrop for your next chapter!

Newest Flamingo Island (49.5) Homes for Sale

$5,399,000
8 Beds ⋅ 8 Baths ⋅ 621248 MLS
Looking for a truly unique opportunity in the Florida Keys? Check out these 2 Custom Luxury CBS Pool Homes that are side by side! Live in one, and rent the other, corporate retreats, weddings, vacation rentals, tons of options! Experience luxury waterfront living in these custom-built, new construction two-story concrete homes featuring 4 bedrooms and 4 private en-suite baths. Designed for entertaining, the open-concept layouts seamlessly blends indoor and outdoor living. The chef's kitchens boasts top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances including double convection ovens, Smart refrigerator, dishwasher, vented range hood, prep sink, wine chiller, quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and a large island. Porcelain tile flooring, custom fixtures, LED lighting, and abundant natural light enhance every space. A first-floor en-suite bedroom offers balcony access overlooking the pool, dock, and water. The dramatic floating staircase with custom LED chandelier leads to three additional en-suite bedrooms upstairs. The primary suite features a floating soaking tub, double vanity, custom porcelain tile shower, and MOEN programmable multi-head shower system with smartphone controls. Additional features include impact windows and doors, web-enabled security camera system, 4K Smart TVs in every room, 8-foot interior doors, two 3-ton 16 SEER A/C units, standing seam metal roof, aluminum railings, and expansive balconies on both levels. Located in the desirable Flamingo Island neighborhood of Marathon, just minutes from Sombrero Beach, dining, shopping, and entertainment. Enjoy quick access to open water, world-class fishing, boating, diving, and the crystal-clear turquoise waters of the Florida Keys. Built to impress and built to last, these exceptional waterfront retreats offer the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle. Set up your preview today!

835 & 837 Copa D Oro, Marathon
$1,295,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 621216 MLS
Discover the potential of this concrete constructed, waterfront pool home tucked away on tranquil Flamingo Island. Offering the ideal opportunity to renovate, personalize, and create your own Florida Keys retreat, this property features three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and nearly 1,300 square feet of interior living space. More than 600 square feet of screened porches invite relaxed indoor-outdoor living, while over 500 square feet of enclosed storage provides valuable additional space for boating gear, bicycles, fishing equipment, and more. Boaters will appreciate the newly constructed 60-foot wood dock, completed in 2025, along with excellent deep-water access through nearby Sister Creek. After a day on the water, unwind beside the concrete pool or enjoy the peaceful island surroundings. Additional improvements include a metal roof installed in 2020 and termite tenting completed in 2025 by Hammerhead Termite Control. Located behind the Florida Keys Golf and Country Club, Flamingo Island is a quiet, dog-friendly waterfront neighborhood close to everything Marathon has to offer. Take the golf cart to Sombrero Beach, Publix, nearby restaurants, and local conveniences. With superior concrete construction, substantial dockage, a private pool, generous outdoor living areas, and an inviting waterfront setting, this fixer-upper presents a rare blank canvas ready to be transformed into your ideal Keys escape.

105 Santa Barbara, Marathon
$1,900,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 620705 MLS
Welcome to 870 Copa D Oro, an exceptional waterfront retreat in the highly sought-after Flamingo Island neighborhood. Offered for the first time in 22 years, this rare property boasts an impressive 190 feet of pristine waterfront on an oversized 12,600-square-foot lot, offering breathtaking water views and endless opportunities for the boating enthusiast. This well-maintained CBS home features 2 bedrooms on the main level with a third bedroom in the upstairs loft, offering 1,560 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space. Rich wood ceilings and an abundance of natural light create a warm, inviting atmosphere filled with timeless Florida Keys charm and character. At the heart of the home is an updated chef's kitchen, complete with a Wolf gas range, new refrigerator, wine cooler, and beautiful wood cabinetry with granite countertops--perfectly blending style and functionality for everyday living or entertaining. Impact-rated doors and windows, screened porches on both the upper and lower levels, and a spacious balcony provide the perfect spaces to relax and take in the stunning waterfront views. Designed for the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle, the property includes a permitted enclosure beneath the home, covered parking, and exceptional dockage featuring a 40-foot dock plus an additional cut-in slip for a smaller vessel, providing room for multiple boats. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, vacation getaway, or premier waterfront investment, 870 Copa D Oro offers an unmatched combination of location, spectacular views, exceptional boating access, and the distinctive charm that makes Florida Keys waterfront homes so special.

870 Copa D Oro, Marathon
$2,149,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 620284 MLS
The Boater's Dream. Navigate the Marathon waters with ease right from your backyard. This property features a 55-foot, new composite dock situated on a deep canal, paired with a 20,000 lb boat lift. Embrace the sunshine in your private, fenced-in backyard. The grounds feature a heated in-ground pool, a screened patio, and a custom outdoor kitchen with a built-in outdoor kitchen--the perfect setup for hosting post-fishing dinners. The property is solid concrete construction and also boasts a brand-new metal roof for ultimate peace of mind. Massive storage, workshop, and garage. The stunning main living area is perched on the second floor, maximizing the beautiful canal views. The open-concept design seamlessly connects the living room to a gourmet kitchen outfitted with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, a wine cooler, and custom cabinetry. The second floor also hosts two bedrooms and two bathrooms, including the spacious master suite. Fully furnished and fortified with impact-resistant doors and windows (plus accordion and Bahama shutters), this home is move-in ready. An interior staircase leads down to a highly desirable feature: a legal, above-flood ground-floor bedroom and full bathroom. An additional bonus room could easily be the fourth bedroom. The lower level is incredibly practical, offering a fully equipped garage, a dedicated storage room, and a workshop for all your maritime gear and tackle. This home is eligible for seven night rentals and would make a tremendous vacation rental investment.

969 Ocotillo Ln, Marathon
$2,799,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 620205 MLS
Discover elevated waterfront living in this newly constructed custom two-story concrete residence, offering 4 spacious bedrooms, each with its own private en-suite bath. Thoughtfully designed for both comfort and entertaining, the home features a seamless open-concept layout that effortlessly connects indoor and outdoor spaces. At the heart of the home is a designer chef's kitchen appointed with premium stainless steel appliances, including double convection ovens, a smart refrigerator, dishwasher, vented range hood, and wine cooler. A large center island with prep sink, quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and elegant LED pendant lighting complete the space. Throughout the home, porcelain tile flooring, designer finishes, and expansive windows create a bright and sophisticated atmosphere. A first-floor guest suite offers balcony access with views overlooking the pool, dock, and canal. The striking floating staircase, accented by a custom LED chandelier, leads to the upper level where three additional en-suite bedrooms await. The luxurious primary suite serves as a private retreat, featuring a freestanding soaking tub, dual vanities, an oversized porcelain tile shower, and a MOEN smart multi-head shower system with app-controlled temperature and spray settings. Additional features include impact windows and doors, a web-connected security camera system, energy-efficient LED lighting, 8-foot interior doors, 4K Smart TVs throughout, dual 3-ton 16 SEER air conditioning systems, a standing seam metal roof, aluminum railings, and spacious balconies on both levels. The property offers dual staircases leading to the outdoor living area, a 12' x 26' custom pool and a 50 foot dock. Ideally located in Marathon's desirable Flamingo Island neighborhood, this exceptional property is just minutes from Sombrero Beach, restaurants, and local attractions. Built with quality, durability, and style in mind, this remarkable waterfront home captures the essence of luxury living.

837 Copa D Oro, Marathon
$2,799,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 620204 MLS
Experience luxury waterfront living in this custom-built, new construction two-story concrete home featuring 4 bedrooms and 4 private en-suite baths. Designed for entertaining, the open-concept layout seamlessly blends indoor and outdoor living. The chef's kitchen boasts top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances including double convection ovens, Smart refrigerator, dishwasher, vented range hood, prep sink, wine chiller, quartz countertops, custom cabinetry, and a large island. Porcelain tile flooring, custom fixtures, LED lighting, and abundant natural light enhance every space. A first-floor en-suite bedroom offers balcony access overlooking the pool, dock, and water. The dramatic floating staircase with custom LED chandelier leads to three additional en-suite bedrooms upstairs. The primary suite features a floating soaking tub, double vanity, custom porcelain tile shower, and MOEN programmable multi-head shower system with smartphone controls. Additional features include impact windows and doors, web-enabled security camera system, 4K Smart TVs in every room, 8-foot interior doors, two 3-ton 16 SEER A/C units, standing seam metal roof, aluminum railings, and expansive balconies on both levels. Situated on an oversized 11,319 sq. ft. corner lot, the property includes a 12' x 26' pool with custom pavers, two stairways to the outdoor living area, and a 36 foot dock completed in January 2024. Located in the desirable Flamingo Island neighborhood of Marathon, just minutes from Sombrero Beach, dining, shopping, and entertainment. Enjoy quick access to open water, world-class fishing, boating, diving, and the crystal-clear turquoise waters of the Florida Keys. Built to impress and built to last, this exceptional waterfront retreat offers the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle. Adjacent property at 837 Copa D'Oro is also available, featuring an 8,200 sq. ft. lot and 50-foot dock.

835 Copa D Oro, Marathon
Start Your Search