Shark Key Homes for Sale

Shark Key Homes for Sale

Welcome to Shark Key, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Florida’s Monroe County. This exclusive island community offers a unique blend of tranquility and luxury, making it the perfect escape for those seeking a serene lifestyle surrounded by natural beauty. Located just a short drive from the vibrant city of Key West, Shark Key boasts stunning waterfront views, lush tropical landscapes, and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like a world away.

Shark Key is renowned for its picturesque scenery, featuring pristine beaches, crystal-clear waters, and abundant wildlife. Residents enjoy a laid-back lifestyle with opportunities for fishing, kayaking, and exploring the nearby Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary. Whether you’re an outdoor enthusiast or simply looking to unwind, this island paradise has something for everyone.

For those considering a move to this idyllic locale, there are a variety of homes for sale that cater to different tastes and preferences. From charming waterfront cottages to luxurious estates, each property showcases the unique character of Shark Key. Many homes feature expansive outdoor living spaces, private docks, and breathtaking views of the surrounding waters, providing the perfect backdrop for entertaining or simply enjoying the sunset.

Investing in a home in Shark Key not only offers a slice of paradise but also the opportunity to become part of a close-knit community that values peace, privacy, and natural beauty. With real estate options available, now is the perfect time to explore your dream home in this enchanting island haven. Discover the allure of Shark Key and let it be the place where your new chapter begins!

Newest Shark Key Homes for Sale

$6,200,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 620499 MLS
Don't miss this rare and exceptional opportunity to have your dream waterfront masterpiece begin construction in 2026! Located in the prestigious, gated community of Shark Key, 36 Cannon Royal is an extraordinary west-facing lot that spans nearly 14,500 square feet and boasts approximately 130 feet of waterfront, delivering breathtaking sunset views over the Gulf waters. The sale of this property includes the completed construction of a 4,624 square-foot single family residence in accordance with the approved architectural plans and all associated permits. This thoughtfully designed 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath home features an elevator, a high-end chef's kitchen, loft, outdoor shower, fire pit, outdoor kitchen, and multiple porches/balconies that set the tone for a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle. The expansive fifty foot resort-style pool with sun ledge completes the vision of perfectly tailored island life. Additional conveniences include a two car garage, ample storage, and large covered patio located on the ground level. 36 Cannon Royal is a fully realized, ready-to-build waterfront estate offering luxurious coastal living, impact-rated construction, and peace of mind without compromising comfort or design. Shark Key residents enjoy exclusive amenities including a clubhouse, private beach, swimming lagoon, and pickleball/tennis courts- just minutes away from the world-class dining, arts, and entertainment of iconic Key West. Current architectural plans of 36 Cannon Royal are pending review by Shark Key ARB.

36 Cannon Royal Dr, Shark Key
$9,999,000
5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 619975 MLS
Introducing an extraordinary and completely custom Polynesian-inspired estate designed by the owner with finishes imported from all over the world. Perfectly positioned on the most premier lot within the exclusive gated enclave of Shark Key, offering an exceptional blend of privacy and waterfront luxury. Set on a sprawling 1.56-acre lot with an impressive 850 feet of water frontage, this custom residence spans approximately 4,622 sq. ft. and captures breathtaking open water views and unforgettable sunset skies. A long private driveway sets a dramatic tone on arrival, winding through lush grounds and passing the tennis court before revealing the home in complete privacy and anticipation. Inside, a grand entry leads into the Chef's Kitchen and Great Room boasting 180 degree water views. Soaring cathedral ceilings, rich mahogany woodwork, and exposed beams create a warm yet striking architectural statement. Walls of glass doors frame open water views and open seamlessly to the expansive wraparound deck, perfect for entertaining or enjoying iconic Keys sunsets. The thoughtfully designed layout separates the North and South wings, connected by a striking mahogany-wrapped hallway that enhances flow and elegance. The main wing is home to all Living Areas and the Primary Suite featuring soaring ceilings, his & her dressing areas and bath featuring imported tile and water views. The South wing offers exceptional flexibility with a second living area and 4 Bedrooms creating a private retreat for family and visitors. A winding staircase leads to a second-floor guest suite with elevated open water views and serene privacy. Intricate coastal tilework throughout and the custom emerald tile roof reinforces the island aesthetic, while impact windows provide durability and peace of mind. Outdoor living is truly exceptional, featuring a wraparound deck, resort-style pool, multiple tiki huts, and a waterfront lounging area ideal for entertaining or relaxing.

87 Cannon Royal Dr, Shark Key
$12,500,000
6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 619953 MLS
This is set to become one of the most striking homes on Shark Key and it's already underway. A rare opportunity to own a completely brand new waterfront home in one of the Florida Keys' most exclusive gated communities. Positioned on Sea Lore Lane, this 18,750 sq ft waterfront lot offers more than 90 feet of pristine shoreline and uninterrupted open water views. Designed by Artibus Design, the residence is currently under construction and envisioned as a nearly 6,000 sq ft modern coastal showpiece with 6 bedrooms and 6.5 bathrooms. Every inch of this home is being thoughtfully built for modern waterfront living, combining bold architecture, expansive walls of glass, elevated finishes, and seamless indoor outdoor flow throughout. This is the appeal of brand new construction in the Keys. Fresh design. Modern materials. Current building standards. A home created for the way buyers want to live today. Inside, expansive open living spaces, gallery style proportions, striking focal points, an indoor gym, and a large entertainment room create a setting that feels both sophisticated and inviting. Outside, a resort style waterfront environment takes center stage with a pool, expansive covered outdoor living spaces, and a large three car garage beneath the home, all designed to maximize the incredible setting and open water views. For a limited time, a buyer has the rare opportunity to step in and customize finishes and details, helping shape the final vision while avoiding the years of planning, approvals, and uncertainty that can come with building in the Florida Keys. With construction already in progress, this is an opportunity to secure one of the most exciting new builds coming to Shark Key before completion. This is more than new construction. It's the opportunity to own one of the island's most exciting new waterfront homes and create something truly exceptional in the Florida Keys.

31 Sea Lore Ln, Shark Key
$5,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 612702 MLS
Located in the prestigious gated community of Shark Key, 30 Cannon Royal Drive is a distinctive waterfront residence inspired by classic Mediterranean design. Architectural details such as soft arches, warm finishes, and elegant lines create a sense of timeless character rarely found in the Lower Keys. Thoughtfully designed to embrace indoor-outdoor living, the home offers spacious interiors filled with natural light and serene water views throughout. Two expansive porches overlook breathtaking sunset vistas, perfectly positioned on a generous 20,438 sq ft lot. The outdoor living experience is equally compelling, featuring a dedicated entertainment area complete with an outdoor fireplace and a private beach--ideal for both relaxed evenings and elevated gatherings. Additional highlights include two garages, an integrated indoor/outdoor speaker system throughout the home, and a dedicated space for a future elevator--offering both comfort and long-term flexibility. Whether enjoyed in its current form or reimagined to reflect a more modern vision, the property presents a rare opportunity to own a home with architectural presence and creative potential just minutes from Key West. Sold furnished with exclusions.

30 Cannon Royal Dr, Shark Key
Start Your Search