Tinglers Island (49.5) Homes with Yes Pets allowed

Welcome to Tinglers Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Marathon, Florida, within the stunning Monroe County. This charming subdivision offers a unique blend of natural beauty and a vibrant community atmosphere, making it the perfect destination for those seeking a serene coastal lifestyle.

Tinglers Island boasts an array of homes that cater to diverse tastes and preferences, with many properties embracing the spirit of Florida living. One of the standout features of this delightful community is its pet-friendly policy, allowing residents to enjoy their homes alongside their beloved furry companions. Whether you have a playful pup or a curious cat, you’ll find that Tinglers Island is a haven for pet lovers.

The homes in Tinglers Island are designed to harmonize with the picturesque surroundings, featuring lush landscaping and inviting outdoor spaces perfect for relaxation and recreation. Residents can take advantage of the nearby waterfront access, ideal for boating, fishing, or simply soaking up the sun on the pristine beaches that Marathon is famous for.

With its close-knit community vibe, Tinglers Island is not just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Enjoy the convenience of local amenities, including shops, restaurants, and recreational activities, all while being surrounded by the breathtaking natural beauty of the Florida Keys.

If you’re looking for a home where you can create lasting memories with your pets and enjoy the coastal lifestyle, Tinglers Island is waiting for you. Come discover the charm of this exceptional subdivision and make it your new home!

Newest Tinglers Island (49.5) Homes with Yes Pets allowed

$8,299,999

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 619460 MLS

Tucked on the private shores and gated community of Tingler Island, this one-of-a-kind dual-waterfront estate is where the Florida Keys lifestyle reaches its fullest expression. Design/Build by D'Asign Source, meet Bella Vista, a coastal-modern renovation. Experience the ultimate coastal dichotomy: wake to the breathtaking panorama of the Atlantic Ocean, while enjoying the calm, effortless convenience of protected canal-front docking. A rare luxury configuration w/ Main Home on the Open Atlantic Ocean to Guest Home on Canal Frontage. Spend your mornings fishing, afternoons floating in your multi-level infinity pool as it disappears into the ocean horizon & evenings gathered around the gas fire pit beneath swaying palms & stars. The 8' wide by 107' concrete dock accommodates two boat lifts (3,000 & 17,000 lbs) w/ water, electric, & lighting along the full seawall, everything a serious boater needs. The single-bedroom Main Home stuns w/ soaring 18-ft vaulted ceilings, exposed wood beams, & a wall of six floor-to-ceiling glass panels that open to frame the Atlantic as your daily backdrop. The gourmet kitchen features Sub-Zero & Wolf appliances, a Miele coffee system, a 10-ft island, Brittanica quartz countertops, & a temperature-controlled glass wine wall. A sea-inspired chandelier, custom wall paneling & thoughtful finishes flow throughout. The expansive Primary Suite anchors the home w/ ocean views, a floating soaking tub, glass rain shower, dual sinks, & a built-in home office tucked into the layout. The private Guest Home above the double garage offers 2 beds, 2 baths, a kitchenette, private balcony, & its own washer/dryer-ideal for guests or family. Outside, resort-style grounds include a gazebo w/ marble dining table, outdoor kitchen w/ Lynx premium grill & fridge, beach sand, fruit garden, Tuuci marine-grade parasols, tiki torches, Coastal Source audio, 1,000 gallon gas tank & full home generator. Bella Vista isn't just a home, it's your Keys life, fully lived.

100 Tingler Ln, Marathon

$5,995,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 618602 MLS

Private oceanfront estate behind the gates of Tingler Island, one of Marathon's most exclusive and sought-after communities. Designed in timeless Caribbean West Indies style, this exceptional residence is perfectly oriented with coveted southern exposure—capturing refreshing ocean breezes, warm natural light, and the rare privilege of both sunrise and sunset views over open water. Set along a premier stretch of true oceanfront, the property offers unobstructed, forever ocean views, highlighted by a spectacular infinity-edge pool that blends seamlessly into the horizon. The setting is serene, private, and truly irreplaceable. Offered fully furnished, the home features travertine marble flooring throughout the main living level, rich hardwood floors upstairs, and beautiful custom woodwork throughout. Light-filled living spaces flow effortlessly, complemented by spacious bedrooms and a well-appointed kitchen ideal for entertaining, complete with a dedicated wine cooler. An upstairs private lounge and bar open to a walk-out oceanview terrace—an unforgettable setting for sunset cocktails and evening gatherings. The bar is equipped with a wine refrigerator, dishwasher, and ice maker for effortless hosting. Additional highlights include a two-car, climate-controlled garage with ample storage. Ideally located within walking distance to Sombrero Beach, with access to a scenic bike and walking path along Sombrero Beach Road, and just minutes from shopping, dining, grocery stores, and golf-cart-friendly island conveniences. Seller financing available for qualified buyers, presenting a rare opportunity to secure a premier oceanfront estate with enhanced flexibility. Homes of this caliber, privacy, and oceanfront position are seldom offered. Schedule your private showing and experience Tingler Island living firsthand.

90 Tingler Ln, Marathon

Start Your Search