Sugarloaf Shores (17.0) Real Estate

Sugarloaf Shores (17.0) Real Estate

Welcome to Sugarloaf Shores, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Monroe County, Florida. This picturesque subdivision, located in the charming city of Sugarloaf, offers a unique blend of natural beauty, tranquility, and vibrant community living.

Sugarloaf Shores is known for its stunning waterfront properties that provide residents with breathtaking views of the surrounding waters and lush landscapes. Imagine waking up to the gentle sounds of nature, where the sun rises over the horizon, casting a warm glow on your home. With direct access to the crystal-clear waters of Florida Bay, this community is a paradise for boating enthusiasts, fishermen, and anyone who appreciates the great outdoors.

The subdivision is characterized by its friendly atmosphere, where neighbors become friends and community spirit thrives. Families and retirees alike are drawn to Sugarloaf Shores for its laid-back lifestyle and the opportunity to enjoy a variety of recreational activities. Whether you're kayaking through the mangroves, enjoying a sunset picnic at a nearby park, or simply taking a leisurely stroll along the scenic streets, there’s something for everyone here.

Conveniently located just a short drive from Key West and other popular destinations, Sugarloaf Shores offers the perfect balance of seclusion and accessibility. With a range of local amenities, including shops, restaurants, and schools, residents can enjoy all the conveniences of modern living while basking in the serene beauty of this coastal paradise.

Come discover the charm of Sugarloaf Shores—your dream home awaits in this idyllic Florida community!

Newest Listings in Sugarloaf Shores (17.0)

$999,000
621067 MLS
Active Permit! Start building today! Save years of planning and permitting with this exceptional 21,600 sq. ft. waterfront parcel in sought-after Sugarloaf Shores. Situated on a wide canal with ocean-side access, this property includes transferable approvals for a single family home with a 100' dock and a 15,000-lb boat lift, along with engineered plans for a custom pool offering the ultimate head start on your Florida Keys dream home. Sugarloaf Shores is renowned for its crystal clear wide canals, mangrove lined paddle board and kayak trails, quiet residential streets, and estate-sized lots. Full architectural plans, engineering reports, and permit documentation are available upon request.

16770 Cypress Rd, Sugarloaf
$1,595,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 620823 MLS
Experience classic Florida Keys waterfront living in this spacious canal-front retreat on Sugarloaf Key, offering boating access, expansive indoor-outdoor living, and just a short drive to Key West. 3,000 square feet of finished living space including 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. Situated on a wide canal with ample room for a future dock, offering the opportunity to create your own boating paradise. The massive chef's kitchen features copious marble countertops, abundant cabinetry, generous seating, and opens seamlessly into the impressive great room--ideal for entertaining family and friends. The open concept living spaces open onto a large canal-side deck that extends your living space outdoors. The spacious primary suite offers tranquil canal views and a spa-inspired bath with a soaking tub positioned to take in the waterfront scenery. A skylit bonus room offers endless possibilities as a fitness room, artist's studio, or sunroom. The nicely landscaped 13,000-square-foot property offers a circular drive, mature tropical plantings, and abundant parking for guests, boats, and recreational vehicles. Whether you're seeking a full-time residence, seasonal escape, or exceptional waterfront investment, this distinctive Sugarloaf Key home offers the space, setting, and Florida Keys lifestyle you've been waiting for.

182 Venetian Way, Sugarloaf
$1,155,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 620753 MLS
Live on the water on one of the largest lots in Sugarloaf Shores, fronting a 70 ft wide crystal clear swimming canal with easy ocean access. Recent upgrades make this home truly turnkey, including a new seawall, a new boat lift 15,000 lbs), and a newer roof. The big ticket items are already done for you. The grounds are the professionally landscaped with mature trees, fruit trees, a custom rock wall, and plenty of space for RVs, boat trailers, or a pool. For boaters and fishermen you'll find a new dock with a covered fish cleaning station with lights and water, and an ice machine. The elevated home itself is fully renovated and fully furnished with a fresh coastal interior. It features Italian porcelain floors, a granite chef's kitchen, and a standout outdoor kitchen, making it a comfortable retreat after a day on the water.

17183 W Green Turtle Ln, Sugarloaf
$950,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 619875 MLS
On a quiet dead-end street in the highly sought-after Sugarloaf Shores community, sits this fully renovated tropical retreat thats reminiscent of something straight out of a secret garden. Set on an oversized, gated and partially fenced parcel spanning over a quarter acre, this rare non-waterfront property offers the kind of lush green space that's nearly impossible to find in the Florida Keys. Towering old-growth foliage, vibrant established plantings, fresh new landscaping, and newly laid sod create a private, enchanted oasis where every corner invites you to slow down and stay awhile. Built in 1981 of solid concrete block construction and elevated on slab, this beautifully reimagined 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 1,548 square feet of airy, light-filled living space with bright neutral finishes and thoughtful details throughout. Every inch has been meticulously renovated, blending modern comfort with effortless island charm. Designed to embrace indoor-outdoor living, the property features multiple lanais and entertaining spaces perfect for morning coffee beneath the palms, sunset dinners with friends, or quiet afternoons surrounded by tropical serenity. The expansive lot offers endless opportunity for future enhancements -- envision a resort-style pool and tiki hut, a greenhouse, outdoor kitchen, play space for the kids, or all of the above. There's room here to truly create your dream Keys compound. Downstairs, nearly 400 additional square feet of enclosed storage and utility space adds incredible flexibility, while the paved 3-car carport with lighting and built-in workspace could easily be transformed into the ultimate outdoor entertaining kitchen or hobby space. Beloved Sugarloaf Shores provides peaceful island living with a scenic miles-long paved path, a laid-back Lower Keys atmosphere, and sought-after school district -- all just 15 minutes from exciting Key West. Rare Keys privacy, greenery, and possibility you may never want to leave.

123 Venetian Way, Sugarloaf
$3,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 619842 MLS
Morning Glory - The Dolphin House is one of those rare oceanfront sanctuaries where time softens, stress fades, and every sunrise feels like it was created just for you. Welcome to Morning Glory - The Dolphin House. There are homes you visit... and there are homes you feel the moment you arrive. Perfectly positioned on an oversized direct oceanfront lot, this extraordinary 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom residence with 2,478 square feet invites you into a lifestyle many dream about--but few ever experience. As you step inside, you are greeted by tasteful coastal elegance, natural light, and sweeping blue-water views that instantly quiet the mind. Every room feels intentional, warm, and beautifully curated. The décor blends sophistication with comfort, creating a space where luxury feels effortless. Imagine waking each morning in your private suite as the first golden light rises over the Atlantic. Open your eyes to endless turquoise water, soft breezes, and the promise of another perfect day. Walk onto the expansive veranda with your morning coffee, where the sunrise slowly paints the sky. In the evening, the moonrise becomes your private show--silver light dancing across the water while the world grows still. Outside, the experience becomes unforgettable. Spend afternoons floating in the pool beneath swaying palms. Gather friends and family for waterfront dining as laughter mixes with the ocean breeze. Slip into the hammock with soft music and your favorite book. End the night beside the fire pit with a warm drink, toasted marshmallows, and stories under a sky full of stars. This is more than a beautiful home. It is where memories are created. Where families reconnect. Where success is celebrated. Where peace returns. For the buyer who has worked hard and now wants to truly live well, Morning Glory - The Dolphin House is not just a property. This is more than a beautiful oceanfront home. It is where memories are created. Where families reconnect. Where success is celebrated. Where peace returns. For the buyer who has worked hard and is ready to live well, truly, Morning Glory - The Dolphin House is not just a property. It is a reward. It is a retreat. It is a lifestyle. It is your chance to own a piece of oceanfront paradise.

17387 E Dolphin St, Sugarloaf
$699,000
619430 MLS
Build Your Dream Home in Sugarloaf Shores! Discover the rare opportunity to develop your very own piece of paradise in the exclusive Sugarloaf Shores! This 8,165 sq. ft. waterfront lot is high, dry, and cleared, offering a perfect blank slate for your dream home in the Florida Keys. With a full 70' concrete seawall, this property is a boater's paradise, providing direct access to both the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico. All permits for construction have been awarded and are in hand, streamlining your path to creating the perfect coastal retreat. Conveniently located just 15 minutes north of Key West and 15 minutes south of Big Pine Key, this property offers the ideal balance of serene living and easy access to vibrant island life. Don't miss your chance to design and build your custom home in one of the most sought-after waterfront communities in the Keys. Imagine enjoying breathtaking water views and endless boating adventures right from your backyard! *Seller is a licensed FL Realtor

17220 Angelfish Ln, Sugarloaf
$998,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 619159 MLS
Botanical Waterfront Compound ~ 3 bedroom/2 bath elevated CBS home on a fenced half-acre, just 20 minutes from Key West and near Sugarloaf schools. Potential for a fourth (4) bedroom, office, hobby room, etc.. Features a swimming pool with full screened outdoor patio surround, and lush tropical landscaping with palms, orchids, agave, and mature mango trees. Two cistern tanks for watering plants, washing boats & vehicles @ approximately 2,500 gallons each tank. Enjoy quick boating access to the Gulf side for premier tarpon, bonefish and permit flats, and close proximity to Sugarloaf Marina for shallow draft outboard vessels. This canal-front property includes a 30' composite dock with fish cleaning station and launching for kayak or paddle board. Additional highlights: detached carport/workshop, storage shed, and large cistern for irrigation and cleaning boats and vehicles etc.. **VA assumable loan @ 2.25% - VA must approve** **VA Assumable Loan @ 2.25% may be a possibility to a qualified VA Buyer** SELLER'S INSURANCES: FLOOD $2,318, WIND $6,683, HOMEOWNERS $2,159.75 **Canal entrance is 3'+/- at low tide**Shallow draft outboard vessels**Buyer to verify if suitable for Buyers' boating needs**

83 Sugarloaf Dr, Sugarloaf
$2,375,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 617951 MLS
Experience elevated waterfront living at this stunning South Point Sugarloaf Key retreat, where open-water serenity meets refined island design. This exceptional five-bedroom, four-bathroom residence is thoughtfully designed to host family and guests with ease, featuring a desirable split-floor plan and expansive living spaces framed by endless turquoise views. The primary suite is a private sanctuary, highlighted by a wall of windows that greets each morning with sweeping vistas of the open Atlantic—an ever-changing canvas of blues that defines life in the Florida Keys. Throughout the home, wall-to-wall water views create a seamless connection between indoor comfort and the surrounding seascape, offering multiple spaces to relax, entertain, and soak in the coastal atmosphere. Set on an impressive 12,500-square-foot lot, the property provides ample room for outdoor living, recreation, and plenty of room for a pool. Boaters will appreciate the 120-foot concrete seawall with davits, delivering effortless access to world-class fishing, diving, and the iconic Lower Keys sandbars. The elevated design allows the entire lower level to transform into an expansive open-air lounge and entertainment area, complemented by a generous storage room for all your boating and island gear, plus abundant parking. Located in one of the Lower Keys' most sought-after neighborhoods, this peaceful waterfront escape is just 15 minutes from Key West, offering the perfect balance of privacy and convenience. Schedule your private showing today—available in person or via live video—and discover the essence of luxury island living.

205 S Point Dr, Sugarloaf
$1,710,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 617353 MLS
Welcome to this spacious canal-front retreat set on an oversized half-acre lot with endless potential. This four-bedroom, 2,605 sq ft home offers a rare combination of water access, outdoor living, and privacy. Enjoy true Florida Keys living with a private concrete boat ramp, a dock, and direct canal access leading to mangrove-lined creeks and open water just minutes away. Whether you're exploring by paddleboard or kayak, or heading out on your boat to world-class fishing and diving, this location makes it effortless. The backyard is designed for relaxation and connection, featuring a pool, spa, and multiple outdoor patio areas, all surrounded by lush, mature tropical landscaping. Inside, the home features a renovated kitchen, bright open living spaces, and a large enclosed back porch that extends your living area and overlooks the pool, spa, and canal. With four bedrooms, generous square footage, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow, the home is ideal as a primary residence, seasonal getaway, or investment property with tremendous upside. Located just minutes from Key West yet surrounded by the peace and natural beauty of Sugarloaf, this property offers the best of both worlds—space, privacy, and direct water access that's hard to find, along with the freedom to create your ideal island retreat.

1481 Sugarloaf Blvd, Sugarloaf
$3,199,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 618532 MLS
Nestled within this 280 ft of concrete walled and gated property lies a tropical oasis that epitomizes Keys living. Situated on a huge,12,000 sq ft corner lot that provides an exclusive island vibe with lots of privacy that comes complete with 200' of canal frontage, a 133' concrete dock, a new 10k lb boat lift, fish cleaning station, and travertine steps into the sparkling water for an enjoyable saltwater swim. Outdoor lighting perfects this entire property along and under the dock and seawall as well. A new higher end fiberglass pool and spa made by Latham which are built with double thick fiberglass complete with heater and chiller is just waiting for you to enjoy after a day on the water or an evening of entertaining. The adjoining new tiki hut, complete with a NewAge summer kitchen, a dining area and ready for happy hours and fish tales. The bar and lounging area located across from the tiki hut provides a comfortable lounging area complete with a nice storage area. Pavers adorn all the open spaces surrounded by new exquisite, lush landscaping maintained by a 5-zone irrigation system. A new standing seam metal roof was installed in 2024. Oh and did I mention a real fire pit. This gorgeous home is all about being outdoors and enjoying the Florida Keys tropical ambiance. The main living area has an open kitchen concept with a center island, gas stove, new appliances, and dining table. Guest bedroom is on the main floor with a full bath and walk in shower. Upstairs has two master suites, one with a stand-alone tub and walk in shower and the other with a walk-in shower only. Two of the bedrooms have balconies overlooking this peaceful, delightful, property. All the furniture is brand new and comes included with the purchase. With the proximity to Key West, and all the excitement and nightlife and the world class fishing and diving out your back door, the world is your oyster in this Fabulous Florida Keys slice of paradise. Don't let this one get away.

17183 Coral Dr, Sugarloaf
$474,000
617936 MLS
Welcome to the lowest priced waterfront lot with an active building permit and DEP and Army Corp mitigation fees paid on prestigious Sugarloaf Key. This oversized 14,706 sq. ft. canal-front property features no-bridge ocean access, granting you instant entry to world-class fishing, diving, and boating. Located in the premier residential enclave of the Sugarloaf Shores, this lot includes an active building permit for a custom 2,120 sq. ft., 4-bedroom, 3-bath coastal-style home -- with Army Corps dock approval already secured. Build today or customize plans to suit your vision. Sugarloaf Key is beloved for its larger lots, upscale homes, and stunning natural beauty. Enjoy crystal-clear water, endless mangrove creeks perfect for paddleboarding or kayaking, and the convenience of being just 15 minutes from Key West. The neighborhood is quiet, well-maintained, and filled with luxury homes offering the perfect setting for full-time living, a vacation retreat, or investment property. Opportunities like this are rare, a cleared path to build in the most coveted location in the Lower Keys. Create your ideal Florida Keys dream home now while you still can!

63 Sugarloaf Dr, Sugarloaf
$5,200,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 618184 MLS
Introducing Blue Sky Pointe - the crown jewel of Sugarloaf Key. Perched on a gated 33,750 sq. ft. peninsula with approximately 730 feet of waterfront, this spectacular 4 Bed, 3.5 Bath modern coastal showpiece is surrounded by glistening water and enjoys Keys famous sunset views over Sugarloaf Sound. Fully renovated with premium craftsmanship, the home features a standing seam metal roof, PGT impact windows/doors, and Hardi board siding. Inside, enjoy a sunlit open-concept floor plan with soaring ceilings, a gourmet kitchen with quartz counters, premium stainless appliances, gas stove, a hidden butler's pantry, and a waterfront Bedroom wing, all oriented to frame the water from every room. Step outside and immerse yourself in resort-style living with a heated and chilled waterfront pool, soothing spa, hot tub, invigorating cold plunge, and a fire pit encircled by flickering tiki torches to gather with friends and family while sipping cocktails as the sun melts into the horizon. Lounge on the expansive covered porch while enjoying views of the peaceful nature preserve for incredible bird watching, and a setting that offers total privacy and serenity. Boaters will love the protected canal access with 2 boat lifts (8K & 12K lbs), just minutes from open water. Additional features include a 4-car garage with EV charger, covered RV Tiki with 50 amp service, whole-house 35kW generator (750-gal tank), whole house water softening system and Sonos throughout, including garage and outdoor zones. Whether you're seeking a private sanctuary, a trophy lot, or the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle, Blue Sky Pointe delivers. This is the most premiere lot on Sugarloaf Key — a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.

17013 Coral Dr, Sugarloaf
Start Your Search